return to homepage

Am I doing 'too much'?

by Phil
(Lancaster MA)

Post workout

Post workout

I’ve been into fitness for a very long time, since my wrestling days in high school and college (when Nixon, Ford & Carter were in office…). My current routine consists of running stairs and lifting weights. I’m very fortunate as we have a very good gym right here in the building, and a back stairwell (72 steps from floor to roof) that gets very little use, so I typically don’t “run into” anyone. So without getting into too much detail, I try to get in 5 workouts a week. They consist of running the stairs and then lifting. My stair routines will vary, some time I just run up and down for 25 to 30 minutes, other times I will mix sprints in, most times I will do some type of HIIT routine. Examples would be walk a flight, run a flight, sprint a flight (a flight consists of full 72 steps up and down, sprints are done taking 2 steps at a time), repeat. Typically do 6 sets which takes around 20 minutes. Another routine would be walk one, run one, sprint two, repeat… or run one sprint one, repeat. From the stairs I have to walk to the other side of the building, takes about 3 minutes, I use this as a cool down period. Once in the gym I cool down for another minute or so, then I begin my lifting routines. My lifting consists of almost all dumbbell exercises and I have 3 routines that I rotate – Chest/Calfs/Ticeps; Quads/Hamstrings/Shoulders & Back/Biceps/Abs. I time these and try to complete the routine in under 25 minutes. I will also change up the particular exercises every couple of weeks, for example I might do one arm dumbbell rows for 3 back routines, then pull-ups for the next 2, then pull overs (on the Nautilus machine) for the next 3, then bent over rows… you get the idea.
This is what a typical routine/day might look like (this is actually my workout for today)


Tuesday – September 28, 2010
Back / Biceps / Abs
Run Stairs – X Minutes (walk-1, run-1, sprint-2 X5 sets)
One Arm Rows 65lbs 1 set 12
Hammer Curls - 30lbs 1 set 12
One Arm Rows 70lbs 1 set 10
Standing Curls - 35lbs 1 set 10 12 Minutes
Machine Curls 100/80/60lbs 1 set 7/5/5
Machine Pullovers – 180lbs 1 set 12
24 Total
Bench Jack Knife 1 set 20
Plank = 1:00
Bench Jack Knife 1 set 20 9 Minutes
Plank = 1:00
Abs 155lbs 1 Set 10
I prefer to lift after I do the stairs as opposed to the other way around. I’ve tried both, I actually feel better after, all warmed up and it allows me to keep a real good sweat while I’m lifting.

Now my question is – Is this too much at once, should I spilt the workouts up and do stairs 3 days, lift 2? Lift 2 days do the stairs 3? I don’t feel any “ill effects”, it’s a great workout when I’m traveling (hotels have great stairwells, not always very good gyms…) there are times I’m only able to get in 4 days a week, never really stress out about it. And on days that for some reason I can only do one or the other, I choose the stairs and may hit them (no pun intended) a little harder adding more sprints, or more sprints in a row. There’s so much information out there and it gets very confusing. A lot of what I’ve read lately leads me to think that doing a HIIT routine than lifting is “bad”, but I’ve been doing it for a couple of years now, as I mentioned, mixing it up pretty frequently, and my 53 year old body doesn’t feel any ill effects. Any and all feedback is welcome. Look forward to hearing what folks have to say.

Comments for
Am I doing 'too much'?

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Two questions
by: Greg

Hey Phil

If its not broken, don't fix it. If you feel good doing it then that's great.

Just two things, I may have missed it but what is your goal here? If its just to stay in shape then that's great.

If you are trying to get better at something or make some changes to yourself then you might want to have a look at your program.

And the second thing, why only one set with your weights? When people usually say do the hiit after weights its usually that you are pushing a few sets and getting close to failure on them. You are not going to get that problem doing only one set but you might not get the results you want?

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Thanks for the response
by: Phil

Greg,

Thanks for the response. I like the ?if it?s not broke? line? OK, let me answer your questions.

My goal is general fitness, to stay in shape. To me it?s much more about ?function? then ?aesthetics?. I want to keep muscle mass, bone density, my cholesterol around 170, blood pressure and resting heart rate well within the ?normal? range, and body fat percentage under 12. Unfortunatley I see a lot of people my age that are out of shape, overweight, on various medications for high blood pressure, high cholesterol, bad back, not being able to sleep? You get the idea.

Also, by function I mean being able to do things I did, could do, years ago. A simple example was at an outing we (my family and I) attended back in July, there was a volleyball tournament. My 2 son?s and I (ages 25 & 22) along with one of their friends made up a team. Everyone else ?my age? sat and watched from the ?sidelines?. We played 5 games, took second place and had a ball. More than one of my contemporaries said ? ?You?re going to be sore tomorrow?. I just smiled, knowing full well that not only would I not be sore, but I didn?t even consider it a workout, it was fun, a little exercise and most of all the boys and I had a lot of laughs. (As a sidebar ? I found it a little sad that people 10 to 15 years younger than me, most of whom were over weight, sat and watched, did not participate.)

I?m not sure what you mean by - ?why only one set with your weights?? My weight workouts are broken into 3 workouts, back/biceps/abs, quads/hamstrings/shoulders & neck, chest/calves/triceps. I do multiple sets for each, focusing mostly on the compound exercises like squats, deadlifts, rows, benches? The workout above is one of the back/biceps/abs routines. I do 2 sets of one arm rows, and a set of pull overs, 3 different sets of curls and 5 ab exercises. I typically do at least 3 exercises per ?body part?. Maybe that wasn?t clear above.

Thanks again for your reply.

Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Training
by: Victoria

I don't see a problem with the routine as long as it's not hurting you, but if you're concerned you should talk to your doctor just to be sure.

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Tabata Training.


Click Here

Web Statistics